Advertisement

Customize
 
 
23 June 2009 @ 06:49 pm
Harper's Island  
GAWD. This show is like crack.












Specifically this is about Wakefield's child.

Spoilery!





So. If not Abby (because the journal did say "child" and not "daughter"), I figured okay, perhaps Wakefield's kid is Henry, and he is Abby's half-brother. They could pass off as siblings imo. If not him, then Jimmy. Jimmy was spared (if he really isn't in on it in the first place), but then... he made out with his half-sister. Ew.

When someone brought up the idea of Sully being Wakefield's offspring, I at first thought, huh, that's random. There's really no backstory to Sully, and it seemed like his days are numbered.

But I've read other people's speculation on TWoP and IMDb and... it isn't impossible.

--->A side-by-side pic someone made of Sully and JW. <---
If I could find the original post, I would credit who made this.

They're even sporting the same facial hair.

ETA: ---> Another side by side made by someone else. <---

I did a quick google and I can still see a resemblance between the actors.


Image and video hosting by TinyPic Image and video hosting by TinyPic


"Are you my daddy?!"
Image and video hosting by TinyPic


Okay, not the best, but I couldn't find many pictures of Matt Barr/Sully at all.

The question is - is it only coincidence? Or can I trust the show to have done this on purpose?

And this doesn't necessarily mean, no matter who his kid his, that they're the killer. If it's Sully, he most likely doesn't even know it. It would be ironic looking back to Sully's reaction to Abby possibly being Wakefield's daughter. I haven't paid enough attention to consider the timeline and all, but judging by numerous comments, it's a possibility and I will just have to trust them on that lol.

Others have pointed out that, in the most recent episode (ep. 10), when they are being shot at, the killer has a clear shot of Trish and Sully but he skips them and moves on to Abby I think. Did he not shoot because he didn't want to kill Trish, or would he have shot Trish, but Sully was behind her, risking him getting hit? Watch, At about 2:27 into this clip.


In the same episode, different shooting, Cal gets shot. It was brought up that the shooting stopped as soon as Sully was in the car and no longer ducking. I watched and it does look like to me that Sully was being shot at as well, maybe not. My opinion changes every time I play the clip.

Judging by the preview for next week, Wakefield probably doesn't have anything to do with the murders we've witnessed. Well, not all of them. It must be someone in the list of 25, now narrowed down to 12 suspects. But, assuming it's Sully as the child, I don't see him having anything to do with the killings. I can't see him pulling it off.

I don't even know if Sully being Wakefield's child, thus making him Abby's half-brother would really add anything to the show, it's probably Henry if anybody, but it's an interesting theory to me at the very least lol. It's been awhile since I'vee over-analyzed a show, I need to do this! :O

Really I just want a reason for Sully to make it as long as possible. I admit! But... it would be nice to get something on Sully, he's survived this long, there has to be a reason if not out of pure luck.

Another thing - There seems to be constant lines and actions that show how cowardly and truly scared Sully is. Kind of funny to think about Wakefield, murderer and all around dickhead, has a son who is a coward. Maybe, pretending Sully is the child and not Abby, or Henry, he discovers the truth. But despite it, he gathers the courage and he (and increasingly kickass Abby) come together and kill Wakefield. Abby would get revenge for what he did (well until the other killer(s) come out) and Sully would show his inner bravery by killing his biological father, John Wakefield of all people... or die trying to kill him, putting up a good fight. Abby will finish the job.

If he is the child though, and also the other killer/accomplice, it would be unexpected, as I think Sully's reactions have been much too genuine. Or he's putting up one hell of an act.

But that's just one way of looking at it. It could very well be Henry (I'm definitely pointing the finger at Henry for being the other killer at least) but it's fun to speculate about this. Jimmy's simply too obvious so I'm trying to rule him out.

What are your speculations, you very few on my f-list who are watching this lol.

P.S I wish I could look as Sully and not be reminded of Spencer Pratt. I would like to un-see that resemblance. :\
 
 
Current Mood: curious
Current Music: Joey mcIntyre - I Love You Came Too Late ( ya rly)
 
+
 
 
 

Advertisement

Customize